Overall · Methodology v1.2
82
81.80 rounded to 82. Tier Gold (70–89). Feedback 40% · Findability 20% · Consistency 15% · Website & Conversion 15% · Editorial 10%. Customer feedback is the primary measure.
Certificate of Local Standing — Gold. Independently rated from public evidence, customer feedback first. Gold is the expected level for an operating practice with a live site and a thick public review book. It is not a claim you are the best dentist in Austin, and it does not mean the listings are finished.
81.80 rounded to 82. Tier Gold (70–89). Feedback 40% · Findability 20% · Consistency 15% · Website & Conversion 15% · Editorial 10%. Customer feedback is the primary measure.
Patients already write like you are their home dentist. Live directories still publish 13917, 12400, and a second phone.
One NAP everywhere: 15955 State Hwy 71 and (512) 402-1818.
Correct Birdeye, WebMD, Healthgrades, and MapQuest to the official address and phone.
Near-five stars, 1,000+ reviews cited, 0 cons in the sample.
Strongest. Birdeye 4.9 / 1,339 Google; dental.me 5.0 / 1,280 (updated 1 Jul 2026).
Gap. Those two counts disagree. Maps page itself was blocked.
Live site + Nextdoor + dental.me. Maps unverified. City best-ofs no.
Strongest. Official site and a Nextdoor page a neighbor can open.
Gap. Not named on Statesman 3 Aug 2026. Yelp / Facebook / Zocdoc blocked, not absent.
One brand name. Address, phone, and hours still drift.
Strongest. Official JSON-LD already says 15955 and (512) 402-1818.
Gap. 13917 and 12400 still live. (737) 238-6528 on two directories.
Live site, Dentist schema, form, proof, membership language.
Strongest. Title has dentist + Bee Cave. Real street in JSON-LD.
Gap. Schema hours (9–5) disagree with the offer page (9–6).
The Austin American-Statesman readers’ list dated 3 August 2026 names five practices. You are not one of them. DenScore’s named Austin lists and Celebrate Dental’s top 10, both opened this pass, also omit you. That is editorial, not a review problem.
Present on the official site, Nextdoor, and dental.me. Stale Healthgrades and blocked Maps / Yelp / Zocdoc are not a yes.
No honest city median for this eight-set: Maps, Yelp, and Zocdoc were blocked for everyone we would have compared.
Mark Sweeney / Austin Dental Spa leads the opened 3 Aug 2026 readers’ list. You are absent there.
tomasikdental.com · Dentist in Bee Cave, TX.
Place page not readable. Not scored as absent.
Name search timed out. Not treated as missing.
Dr. Tomasik · 12400 / Soft Touch PLLC · 5.0 / 2.
15955 · (512) 402-1818 · Favorite 2022–2024.
Cites Google 5.0 / 1,280 · updated 1 Jul 2026.
Opened. Your name is not on the 3 Aug 2026 list.
Austin dentists host timed out. Not absent.
On the Austin table we opened: 5.0 / 671, Dental.me Score 98. Same host that cites you at 5.0 / 1,280. Southwest Austin corridor, not a quality judgment.
Opened table: 5.0 / 716, Score 98. Also named under “Other Top Dentists” on the opened DenScore Austin page. You are not on that DenScore named list.
Mark Sweeney, DDS. Lead entry on the opened Statesman page dated 3 Aug 2026. Address on that page: 3305 Northland Dr, Suite 515. That is the editorial list you are not on.
Fifteen review texts opened. Cons retrieved: none. The product story is Gold-shaped. The public count is large on every aggregator we opened — and those aggregators do not agree on one Google number.
Lucia, Shelly Bull, Melissa, Hannah, Stephanie named. Crowns / veneers: Nicky B., Taylor H. Cost-transparency / membership: Logan E., Kelly Brown. Price words appear as “transparent” and “affordable plan,” not a dollar rate.
4.9 · 0 Birdeye-native. Texts labeled 5 months ago.
5.0 · page updated 1–2 Jul 2026.
4.9 · third opened count. Do not pick a winner.
Peers on the same dental.me table: Broberg 671 · 38th Street Dental 716. That host says your cited volume beats 98% of Austin practices. Recency. Newest Birdeye texts we could read are ~5 months old. Nextdoor recs: 4 Aug and 27 Jul (year not printed). Maps recency is unknown.
“The cleanliness at this dental office is top tier, everything you are surrounded by is clean!!! … Dr. Shahi is a fantastic dentist and actually caught something that 3 other dentists did not catch.”
Ashley · Google via Birdeye · labeled 5 months ago · page live 19 Aug 2026
“Dr. Prieto and Stephanie were absolutely amazing! I actually feel like all my questions and concerns regarding my teeth were answered and they were both so so thorough.”
Lillie Brayton · Google via Birdeye · labeled 5 months ago · page live 19 Aug 2026
“Best dental experience ever!!!”
I. H. · Austin, TX · Nextdoor · 4 Aug (year not printed on the page)
Tomasik Family Dental is the Bee Cave / Hwy 71 practice patients describe as a clean, hospitality-first family office where named hygienists and doctors take the fear out of the chair. That is the product. It is not yet one address and one phone on every live directory, and it is not a Statesman best-of line.
Every opened review in the sample is praise. You do not lose Austin because patients are unhappy. You lose it when a stranger lands on 13917, 12400, or (737) 238-6528, and when the city newspaper’s dentist list does not contain your name.
We opened a Maps shell. No rating or count was readable. That is BLOCKED, not absent. The homepage has a Maps embed and a Google Reviews logo; those are not an independent GBP read. Birdeye says 4.9 / 1,339. dental.me says 5.0 / 1,280 (1 Jul 2026). dentistryexcellence says 4.9 / 989. Do not pick one number and print it as “our Google score.”
Official JSON-LD: 15955 State Hwy 71, Austin, TX 78738, (512) 402-1818. Birdeye and WebMD still list 13917 Hwy 71 Ste B. Healthgrades (last verified 7 Apr 2026) and MapQuest still list 12400 W Highway 71 Ste 320 / Bee Cave Soft Touch Dental PLLC. dental.me and dentistryexcellence publish (737) 238-6528.
1. Live site. Title already says dentist and Bee Cave.
2. Dentist JSON-LD with the real street, city, phone, and geo. No invented star rating in the fetched schema.
3. Contact form, email, testimonials, membership / financing language (amounts withheld).
1. Title is Bee Cave, not Austin — the city query this report used.
2. Schema hours Mon–Thu 9–5 / Fri 9–2 vs the offer page Mon–Thu 9–6 / Fri 8–3.
3. “Read more Google Reviews” points at a logo; we still could not open Maps.
Publish one hour block and one phone on every page you own, then push 15955 + (512) 402-1818 to Birdeye, WebMD, Healthgrades, and MapQuest. Schema will not fix a ghost address on a live host.
dental.me ranks you #1 of 515 on their score. That is a vendor directory, not “best dentist in Austin.” Community Impact (16 Jul 2025) is real local press — owners, 15955 Hwy. 71, tomasikdental.com. Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite 2022–2024 is a neighbor mark. The pages that rank for “best dentist Austin” that we opened — Statesman 3 Aug 2026, DenScore’s named lists, Celebrate’s top 10 — do not name you. Pitch the Statesman readers’ choice. Do not advertise dental.me #1 as a newspaper award.
Exact listing name on every host: Tomasik Family Dental. Exact address: 15955 State Hwy 71, Austin, TX 78738. Exact phone: (512) 402-1818.
Move Birdeye and WebMD off 13917. Move Healthgrades and MapQuest off 12400 / Soft Touch PLLC. Same name, same 15955, same (512) 402-1818.
Ask dental.me and dentistryexcellence to drop (737) 238-6528 if that is not the public line. Align homepage JSON-LD hours with the offer page. Pick one and use it everywhere.
You were not on the 3 Aug 2026 list (Sweeney, Carter, DeMarco, Hauser, Bell). Send the Community Impact 15-year note, the Nextdoor 2022–2024 Favorite, and three published photos. That is a pitch, not a claim you already won.
1. Suggest-edit Birdeye to 15955 State Hwy 71.
2. Same edit on WebMD, Healthgrades, MapQuest.
3. Lock one public hour block on the site and the offer page.
1. Confirm a Maps URL a stranger can open. Do not print a Google count until it does.
2. Retire (737) 238-6528 on dental.me if it is not the line you answer.
3. Add “Austin” next to Bee Cave in the homepage title if you want the city query.
4. Enter the next Statesman Community’s Choice cycle.
1. Open Yelp and Facebook under the same NAP (those hosts were blocked this pass — do not assume they are empty).
2. Keep asking patients to name Bee Cave / Austin and the doctor or hygienist.
3. Pitch DenScore only after NAP is one cluster.
4. Re-score in 30 days. This Snapshot expires 19 Sep 2026.
“Hi — it’s the team at Tomasik Family Dental. We’re updating the listings neighbors actually use (Google and Nextdoor). If you have two minutes, a short review would mean a lot. First sentence, if you’re willing: Tomasik Family Dental in Bee Cave is our family dentist. Thank you.”
Listing name. Tomasik Family Dental
Address. 15955 State Hwy 71, Austin, TX 78738
Phone. (512) 402-1818 (official). (737) 238-6528 appears on dental.me and dentistryexcellence — treat as a conflict, not a second official line until you confirm it.
Email. [email protected]
Site. https://www.tomasikdental.com/
Statesman pitch. https://www.statesman.com/best/map/best-dentists-austin/ — you are not on it. Ask for the next readers’ list, not a rewrite of 3 Aug 2026.
Customer Feedback 90 × 0.40 = 36.00 · Findability 80 × 0.20 = 16.00 · Consistency 72 × 0.15 = 10.80 · Website & Conversion 88 × 0.15 = 13.20 · Editorial 58 × 0.10 = 5.80
36.00 + 16.00 + 10.80 + 13.20 + 5.80 = 81.80 → 82 / 100 → Gold (70–89). Customer-facing four (same facts): Feedback 90 · Findability 80 · Consistency 72 · Conversion 88. Maps BLOCKED is a cap, not a dump. The old 5-dimension worker is extra search evidence only.
| Source | State | Fact |
|---|---|---|
| Official site / about / contact | VERIFIED PRESENT | tomasikdental.com · Dentist JSON-LD 15955 · (512) 402-1818 |
| Google Maps / GBP | BLOCKED | Place page not readable. Not treated as absent. Do not use 1,280 / 5.0 as Maps. |
| Birdeye | VERIFIED PRESENT | 4.9 / 1,339 Google · address 13917 (inconsistent) |
| dental.me | VERIFIED PRESENT | 5.0 / 1,280 cited · updated 1 Jul 2026 · phone (737) |
| Nextdoor | VERIFIED PRESENT | 15955 · (512) · Favorite 2022–2024 |
| Healthgrades / MapQuest | STALE | 12400 / Soft Touch PLLC · 5.0 / 2 on Healthgrades |
| WebMD | INCONSISTENT | 13917 Ste B · 0 ratings · (512) 402-1818 |
| Yelp / Facebook / Zocdoc | BLOCKED | Not treated as absent. Facebook URL is in official sameAs. |
| Statesman / DenScore / Celebrate | VERIFIED ABSENT | Opened. Name not on those lists. |
| Community Impact | VERIFIED PRESENT | 16 Jul 2025 · 15th year · 15955 Hwy. 71 |
78 — 14 of 18 priority sources. In N: homepage, about, contact, new-patient NAP, Birdeye, dental.me, Healthgrades, Nextdoor, Statesman, DenScore, Celebrate, Community Impact, WebMD, MapQuest. Not in N: Maps, Yelp, Zocdoc, Facebook (all blocked). Maps timeout counts as not verified.
No independently opened Google star/count. Three aggregators disagree (1,339 / 1,280 / 989). Yelp, Facebook, Zocdoc, Instagram blocked. Live worker overall was null — old engine, not v1.2. No invented phone. No dollar prices (schema $$ withheld). This is not a claim they are the best dentist in Austin.